#MissingEpisodesMonday: Why I think more missing episodes are coming back – and WHAT I think is coming back …

I’ve been sitting on this post for quite a while, realising that predictions are the worst kind of attention seeking, and unable to find any hard evidence to back up my suppositions. As it is, with rumours rumbling that Doctor Who fans will have more to celebrate than the Power of the Daleks animation, I have decided to take the plunge and join in with my own speculation! Readers should note the health warning in advance of this post – I really do not have any proof to back up my suppositions. I think I am right, but it is entirely possible I am wrong.

Let me begin by returning to an original tweet sent out in June 2015:

Tweet by BBC Worldwide

We do have a hard fact to work with here: that as early as June 2015, the BBC were contemplating the release of further classic Doctor Who material. Since then both the BluRay of the TV Movie and the Power of the Daleks animation have indeed been announced, fulfilling their hope to release ‘more.’ As my post from the time also notes, this was right in the middle of the ‘Will they or won’t they?’ release of The Underwater Menace. So, on the face of it, it is simple – we know the three hoped for releases.

Except it does not seem that straightforward. Judging by what we know from elsewhere, the animation of Power was due to BBC America deciding to make funding available both to commission the animation, and also to broadcast it in America. The animation team involved is the same team that animated the lost Dad’s Army episode ‘A Stripe for Fraser.’ – a project that concluded in January. Taking these two facts together, it seems unlikely that the BBC were thinking of The Power of the Daleks when this tweet was made. Similarly, it seems unlikely that they were thinking of The Underwater Menace, given that this particular DVD release seems to have been made with reluctance, and I have always thought that ‘more’ classic Doctor Who means more than special editions or high definition. The conclusion I am forced to, is that the BBC still anticipate the return of more material that is currently ‘officially missing.’

The obvious candidate for more returned material would be Web of Fear episode 3, given that Philip Morris said in his Starburst interview: “we’re on top of that.” It seems to be accepted that we will eventually get Web 3, and there seems to be acceptance that we will get more material, whether orphans or complete serials. It also seems to be accepted that the omnirumour was the galloping fancy of fans who couldn’t resist entertaining the prospect of being able to watch (almost) every single episode of Doctor Who ever made. So what we are looking at, is a number between 2 and 97 … and now I am going to predict what I think we are going to get.

To do so, credit is due to The Destruction of Time website (http://missingepisodes.blogspot.co.uk/) and in particular their page detailing which overseas nations are believed to have screened lost Doctor Who, available at THIS LINK. I am also grateful to Jon Preddle, who gave a very detailed email reply to some of my questions about which serials were sold in ‘packages.’ All of my deductions are based on the premise that if I think one story is back, that increases the likelihood that other stories sold in that cluster are also back. So, with that in view, here is what I think we can look forward to:

Highly Probable: The Abominable Snowmen and The Wheel in Space

I am not the first person to speculate that these stories ought to be back. These were included in the same package as Enemy of the World and Web of Fear, so on paper they ought to have been in Jos. Possibly, like Web 3 they went walkies. Possibly they were sent on to a different station. My own persuasion is that the revelation Web 3 exists is good news for these stories – it changes the perception of Jos from ‘fortunate that only one episode was lost’ to ‘everything was there.’ I am fairly confident that both these stories were found in Nigeria – as with all of these recoveries, the unknowable question is whether they are salvageable. Given the BBC’s optimism however, I predict that a future release may well be a Great Intelligence boxset featuring the newly completed Web of Fear alongside the newly recovered Abominable Snowmen.

Suspected Probable: The Crusades and The Underwater Menace

It has always puzzled me why the BBC drew stumps on animations after The Moonbase, given that two other stories satisfied the criteria of not having more than half their content missing, and only requiring two episodes to be animated to complete the story. It is even more puzzling that when The Underwater Menace was released, not only did the BBC use rather telesnaps, they also refused to let the restoration team rearrange the telesnaps to reflect the story being told – meaning that it is incredibly difficult to follow the story. It is useful to reflect that the BBC did not rush an animation for the missing episode of Web of Fear, rather suggesting that they knew from the start that it was out there somewhere, and it was worth being patient.

I am therefore entirely persuaded that both stories exist, and the BBC is holding fire in the hope that they reach the BBC archives. As with all of these ‘finds’, there is no guarantee either that the stories are in a recoverable state, or that those holding the prints are willing to part with them. The balance of probability however, is that the absence of animations for these two adventures is best explained by the prospect that the animations would very soon become superfluous.

The possibilities: perhaps the entirety of Seasons 1 and 4 …

From this point onward, we enter deepest, darkest speculation. As with all of the health warnings thus far, there is no guarantee that individual stories or episodes were not siphoned away from the main package, or suffered more damage than others. If, however, episode packages have indeed remained intact in overseas film depots, then here are the possibilities that we might entertain.

If the Crusades has been recovered, then we can be absolutely confident that the missing episodes from season 1 have been recovered as well. Every country that bought The Crusades also bought Marco Polo and The Reign of Terror. On that premise, I am prepared to predict that the entirety of the first two seasons of Doctor Who exists somewhere, and the only question is whether the material is still salvageable, and whether it is possible for the BBC to access the material.

If the Underwater Menace is back, and the entirety of its package is intact, that means that at worst the Uganda prints have survived. That would mean the recovery of Marco Polo, The Reign of Terror, The Highlanders, The Moonbase, The Macra Terror, and The Faceless Ones. We already know that Phil Morris has searched Zambia and (supposedly) found nothing; if that information is erroneous, and the rescued copy of Underwater Menace is from Zambia, then the metaphorical jackpot has been well and truly hit. In addition to the above, the Zambia prints would also include The Crusades, Galaxy 4, The Myth Makers, The Massacre, The Celestial Toymaker, The Savages, The Smugglers, The Ice Warriors, and The Space Pirates (technically also The Abominable Snowmen – but I presume it has already been found in Nigeria!)

This represents a best and worst case scenario if The Underwater Menace has indeed been found – and even the ‘worst case scenario’ is still pretty fantastic! There are three outside possibilities that on the whole can be discounted – the prints from Hong Kong, New Zealand, and Australia. These prints seem to be well accounted for, and it is unlikely they have been found. It is worth noting that if our assumptions about these prints are wrong however, then we cannot rule out the possibility of the omnirumour being true. If The Underwater Menace is in the Hong Kong prints, along with the rest, then the only story (intriguingly!) missing from the Troughton era is … The Power of the Daleks. I still maintain that if Power ever gets recovered, that means that everything (or almost everything) is back.

A final note of caution is that we have never been entirely sure how many overseas prints have been in circulation – read this earlier post for a short explanation why this is the case. If there are other prints we didn’t know about, then obviously the theorizing above is entirely redundant!

In conclusion – I have focused on two fixed facts. Enemy of the World and Web of Fear survived in their entirety, and the BBC have acted very strangely over the non-animation of The Crusades and The Underwater Menace. My suppositions do rest on certain presumptions – that the episode packages have survived intact in their entirety; that no episodes are lost, water damaged, or held by private collectors; and that the person responsible for finding the episodes (whether Philip Morris or A.N.Other) is able to return them to the BBC – and I freely concede that any and all of those might be the case. Even if just one is true, my case falls flat.

If my supposition is correct however, then I think this is the list of definite recoveries. It is by no means exhaustive, and we may have even more to look forward beyond this list. But I am prepared to stick my neck out, and predict that the following stories have been found:

  1. Marco Polo (7 episodes recovered)
  2. The Reign of Terror (2 episodes recovered)
  3. The Crusades (2 episodes recovered)
  4. The Highlanders (4 episodes recovered)
  5. The Underwater Menace (2 episodes recovered)
  6. The Moonbase (2 episodes recovered)
  7. The Macra Terror (4 episodes recovered)
  8. The Faceless Ones (4 episodes recovered)
  9. The Abominable Snowmen (5 episodes recovered)
  10. The Web of Fear (1 episode recovered)
  11. The Wheel in Space (4 episodes recovered)

37 recovered episodes, leaving 60 still missing

If the rumours are true, we may be about to find out in November just how disastrously wrong I am. Watch this space – and expect the unexpected!

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “#MissingEpisodesMonday: Why I think more missing episodes are coming back – and WHAT I think is coming back …

  1. Why November? Just because power is released then doesn’t mean anything else will be. Good blog though. Would love 37 more recovered.

    Like

    • November is purely what I have been hearing through fan whispers. As ever, these things must be taken with a pinch of salt.
      In that respect the recovery of Web/Enemy is a bit of a pain, as that was one occasion where the rumour mill was correct!

      Like

  2. As Phil Morris said “You’ll get more Doctor Who when you least expect it” I would least expect to get more missing who in the same month as the power animation is released, so you never know!

    Like

  3. Pingback: Are we getting hints The Smugglers is back? |

  4. Two comments here:

    1. Have you made any similar speculations in the past that haven’t panned out? (No offence is intended; I’m just curious.) As with most rumors, I’m taking this with a pinch of salt (as you suggested), but in the back of my mind I’m imagining what would happen if this time the rumors were true.

    2. I have my own theory about the lack of animation for “The Crusade”. It’s true that, based solely on the “no more than two missing episodes” criteria, that story might qualify for animation. However, I get the impression that the BBC had no intention of animating “The Crusade” (or that the idea was abandoned at a very early stage), as the story was probably deemed too politically incorrect for the DVD to be commercially viable. On the other hand, although they seemed reluctant to release “The Underwater Menace”, the Restoration Team did produce DVD extras for that story, saying afterwards that this was the last release they were working on. (This was long before they were handed the prints for Web and Enemy.) Regarding the deliberately bare-bones reconstruction of the missing episodes of “The Underwater Menace”, I have no idea why they did that.

    Like

    • Hi! No offence taken at all.
      To answer each in turn: (1) I’ve not had any rumours proven or disproven. I like to stress throughout that I only ever have ideas – I hope they are right, but I have no proof!
      (2) Interesting theory on The Crusades. I’m not sure how well it stands up given that the likes of Talons of Weng Chiang still managed to get released. However unPC it is, I like to think there would be an understanding that it was from a different time with different standards.

      Like

  5. I personally think the lack of animation for UWM and Crusade was simply a lack of finances in the BBC budget at the time. We only have Power being animated because of BBC America. It’s the age of austerity in the UK , and has been since 2010. Do wish we could have more “finds” but I’m not convinced anything is imminent.

    Like

    • A valid thought – though I also gather that the RT were happy to do Loose Cannon style telesnaps for UWM at no extra charge, and the BBC expressly forbade them. Hence it is the poor quality of the reconstruction that puzzles me.

      Like

  6. It puzzles me to. Maybe a lack of interest in the “product” at that time from BBC world Wide. Don’t know and its these types of nonsensical decisions that add to the rumour mill. If the RT were going to do it for free then surely it was a no-brainer. An opportunity to improve its product ie UWM which could lead to increased sales etc. It makes no sense in any way, shape or form. If further episodes had been recovered or not, it still makes no sense.

    Like

  7. Pingback: Enjoying the #missingepisodes: The Abominable Snowmen |

  8. Pingback: 31 – The Web of Fear |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s